The comparative-historical method of studying biographies: heroes of the Great Patriotic War Tulush Kechil-ool and Bauyrzhan Momyshuly
Сравнительно-исторический метод изучения биографий: герои Великой Отечественной войны Тулуш Кечил-оол и Бауыржан Момышулы
Kilash R.Z. Otepova G.E. Karimova A.E.
2022Ch. K. Lamazhaa
New Research of Tuva
2022Issue 1253 - 265 pp.
The article makes an attempt at historical comparison of the biographies of the Heroes of the Soviet Union Tuvan Tulush Kechil-ool and Kazakh Bauyrzhan Momyshuly. The use of the comparative historical method in analyzing their biographies is based on Plutarchs principle of binarity and the unity of J. M. Coopers notion of chronology of biographies. Comparison allows the authors to reveal similarities and differences in the heroes personalities. Bothbelonged to the Turkic peoples, took the professional path before joining the army, had a military career of an officer, were famous for their heroic deeds, personal qualities, and were awarded the distinction of the Hero of the Soviet Union. The unity of their lifepaths is explained in connection with the history of the country and people, and also with important historical events. Until now, historians have not paid enough attention to the fact that when both commanders were nominated for the title of Hero of the Soviet Union during the Great Patriotic War, they did not receive this title at that time. Tuvan historians have put forward a hypothesis that the reason for this was Kechil-ools belonging to the repressed clan of Adyg-Tyulyushi. As for Momyshuly, Kazakhstani historians have not yet fully clarified this situation. Both officers were outstanding representatives of their peoples, and their memory is carefully preserved, and their lives are in the focus ofhistorians studies. A comparative historical analysis of the biographies of two outstanding representatives of the Tuvan and Kazakh peoples showed their role in the history of their peoples, and how lives are inclose connection with the historical process.
Bauyrzhan Momyshuly , biography , comparative historical method , Great Patriotic War , Kazakh people , Tulush Kechil-ool , Tuvans
Text of the article Перейти на текст статьи
The “History” Educational Program, Pavlodar Pedagogical University, 58 Toraygyrov St., Pavlodar, 140002, Kazakhstan
“History” Educational Program, High School of the Humanities, Pavlodar Pedagogical University, 58 Toraygyrov St., Pavlodar, 140002, Kazakhstan
High School of the Humanities, Pavlodar Pedagogical University, 58 Toraygyrov St., Pavlodar, 140002, Kazakhstan
The “History” Educational Program
“History” Educational Program
High School of the Humanities
10 лет помогаем публиковать статьи Международный издатель
Книга Публикация научной статьи Волощук 2026 Book Publication of a scientific article 2026